We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more›

How We Review

This page explains how PickTheVacuum chooses, compares, and rates the products in our guides. We want you to be able to judge our recommendations for yourself.

What our reviews are based on

Our reviews are research-based. We assess products using:

  • Manufacturer specifications, product pages, and user manuals
  • Published documentation such as warranty terms and replacement part listings
  • Direct comparison of the same features across competing models

We do not run our own lab measurements or in-home trials, and we do not claim to. When a manufacturer does not publish a figure, we say so rather than estimate it.

Our process

  1. Set the criteria first. Before we look at individual products, we decide what matters for that category and for the people who buy it.
  2. Build a shortlist. We look for models from established brands that are currently available, covering a range of budgets and needs.
  3. Check the details. We compare specifications against the manufacturer’s own documentation. Where sources disagree, we use the manufacturer’s published figure or describe the feature without a number.
  4. Score every product the same way. Each product in a guide is rated with the PTV Score, using the same criteria and weights.
  5. Explain the trade-offs. Each pick gets balanced pros and cons and a clear note on who should skip it.
  6. Review and update. An editor reviews every guide before it is published. We update guides when models are replaced or when we find an error.

The PTV Score

The PTV Score is our editorial rating out of 10. We rate each product from 1 to 10 on five criteria, then combine them using fixed weights. The overall score is rounded to one decimal place.

CriterionWeightWhat we look at
Cleaning capability35%Nozzle and brush roll design, filtration, dust capacity, and cleaning modes, as published by the manufacturer.
Ease of use & upkeep20%Weight, emptying, filter and brush care, and manufacturer-stated noise levels.
Build & support15%Warranty length, and whether replacement parts, filters, and batteries are sold.
Versatility15%Included tools, supported floor types, and conversion options such as stick to handheld.
Value15%Features and support relative to other models in the same price tier.

The PTV Score is not based on Amazon star ratings or customer review counts, and brands cannot pay to change it. Affiliate commissions have no effect on scores.

How the criteria apply by type

The five criteria stay the same across the site, but what we look at within them depends on the type of machine:

  • Robot vacuums: navigation type, obstacle avoidance, dock features, app controls, and how the brand handles camera and map data.
  • Stick and handheld vacuums: stated runtime by mode, battery replacement options, bin size, and weight.
  • Upright and canister vacuums: brush roll design, bagged or bagless design, filtration, hose reach, and floor tools.
  • Carpet and hard floor cleaners: tank design, floor compatibility, drying, and self-cleaning features.
  • Shop vacuums: tank size, filter options for fine dust, wet pickup features, and hose diameter.

What the PTV Score does not cover

Scores compare products within the same guide. A 9.0 robot vacuum and a 9.0 shop vacuum are not directly comparable. Scores also reflect the information available when we published or last updated the guide.

Safety and health claims

Some products carry safety considerations, such as lithium-ion batteries, steam, hot ash, or using electrical equipment around water. We point these out and refer you to the manufacturer’s instructions. We do not make health or medical claims. When a manufacturer markets features such as allergen filtration or dust mite removal, we report the claim as the manufacturer states it.

Corrections

If you find an error in any guide, please contact us. Our Editorial Policy explains how we handle corrections and updates.